Has Microsoft redeemed itself?

By the end of 2009, a case was being made that Microsoft had pulled its reputation back from the damage of 2008. Windows 7 had reached general release on 22 October 2009, and the beta versions of the company’s 2010 server and Office products were drawing praise from reviewers at InfoWorld.

The question mattered because 2008 had been a poor year for the company’s image. Windows Vista was widely mocked, Microsoft was criticised for being slow to admit its problems, and security lapses continued. Office 2007 also divided users, with its ribbon interface irritating long-time customers and Mac users complaining about a buggy, less capable Office for their platform.

The Vista hangover

The 2009 recovery began with a change of tactics. Microsoft stopped defending Vista and put its effort behind Windows 7, which it tested publicly in a broad beta. Hundreds of thousands of users, and possibly millions, tried the software more than six months before it shipped.

The reception was largely positive. InfoWorld columnist Randall C. Kennedy had been disillusioned with Microsoft’s decisions for several years and was a favourite of Windows critics, yet he repeatedly praised Windows 7. InfoWorld Test Center reviewer Curtis Franklin Jr. rated it nearly as good as Apple’s Mac OS X Snow Leopard, and he meant that as a compliment. Kennedy’s Windows Pulse service also indicated that users were adopting Windows 7 strongly, including people moving from Windows XP.

IT departments had never left

Inside corporate IT, the damage had been smaller. Many businesses had skipped Vista and kept Windows XP running through the 2008–09 recession, so the reputational problem fell mostly on consumers and desktop users.

The server side also gave administrators reasons for optimism. InfoWorld’s Test Center gave Windows Server 2008 R2 good marks in 2009, citing improvements to Hyper-V R2, Server Core, PowerShell scripting and Terminal Services. Two features were designed to work with Windows 7 clients: BranchCache and AppLocker.

Betas of Exchange 2010 and SharePoint 2010 were also well received. InfoWorld’s Enterprise Windows blogger J. Peter Bruzzese was enthusiastic about both, though he was far from alone. Office Web Apps, Microsoft’s browser-based companion to Office, also looked promising at that stage.

Office and the ribbon

Office had weathered its own controversy. The ribbon had alarmed many experienced users, but the backlash did not stop adoption. Most users seemed untroubled, while objectors either stayed on the older version or learned how to bring back the menus they missed in Office 2007.

The Office 2010 beta won strong praise from InfoWorld blogger Neil McAllister, a demanding reviewer. He judged that Microsoft’s habitual claim that each release reflected user feedback and testing was true this time.

The optimism came with a caveat. These were beta products, with the holes and flaws that come with that status, and Microsoft could still waste the goodwill if it failed to fix the issues that beta testers tolerate early on.

How the products aged

Microsoft’s own lifecycle dates show how long the 2009–10 products stayed in service. Windows 7 left extended support on 14 January 2020, and the company’s paid Extended Security Updates for it ended on 10 January 2023.

The server and Office products praised in the 2010 betas followed a similar course:

  • Office 2010: mainstream support ended on 13 October 2015, and extended support ended on 13 October 2020, with no extension or extended security updates offered.
  • Exchange Server 2010: support ended on 13 October 2020.
  • SharePoint 2010 and Project Server 2010: support ended on 13 April 2021.

Microsoft says Office 2010 apps still run after support ended, but the company will no longer provide bug fixes or security fixes for newly discovered vulnerabilities. By the time of those deadlines, the products that had helped restore Microsoft’s standing in 2009 were roughly a decade old.